94 Comments
User's avatar
LysergicSurya's avatar

Indians managed to retain a broadly sympathetic sentiment in the UK until very recently, with Dvija Hindu doctors and rustic Punjabi factory workers being seen as basically law-abiding, industrious and willing to integrate, if liable to overly aromatic cooking.

The recent proliferation of Boriswave Deliveroo Shudras in the UK has tarnished all our names. That, and the crimes of our increasingly restive Pakistani Muslim cousins whom the average White Brit struggles to conceptually distinguish us from.

Balkanized Cope's avatar

Does the term foot in the door mean anything to you. Or does your pet like admiration of the first round of migration via poetics mean more?

Yatt_96's avatar

There are ethnic differences between the old & new migrants tbh.

Indus Valley (Punjab) v Gangetic.

Balkanized Cope's avatar

So you imported your petty caste divisions? I did business in India for a decade. So your telling me you imported all that petty shit where each caste LARP who is more white?

I sold white skin cream btw. Marketed as a value added good from Switzerland. We had a dutch teenage blue eyed girl on the label. Maybe you have seen it.

Yatt_96's avatar

We're on the border with Pakistan and cluster with Afghanistan more than mainland India. Are you going to tell the North East who look like Chinks the same thing?

Caste is wrong simply because it lets niggers live.

Yonah Ha-I (יוֹנָה הָאִי)'s avatar

No, as someone living in England and privy to private discussions among native Whites, they never viewed having Indians as desirable. Southall & Wembley & Leicester have always been regarded with derision.

sadly_life's avatar

It’s not a hard problem, it is just a matter of will, unlike say deporting 10 million illegals which seems like fantasy to me. I say this as someone very familiar with the tech industry (have worked years in so called Big Tech) and the Indian situation. Most Indians, especially the competent tech workers that are on H1b getting 200k+ salaries are on an H1b that gets renewed every year while they’re waiting for their green cards (which has a multiple decades long wait line). Just don’t renew their H1bs and they’ll leave, they’re not going to become illegal fast food workers just to stay in US, they have a reasonably pleasant life waiting for them back in India (sucks if they’re a fan of skiing though).

But there’s also a large number of illegal Indians in US now, and a lot of supposedly legal Indians who are just gaming the system through consultancies and other scams. The 100k requirement for every H1b application (even one time is fine) would kill most of this. Honestly I think 100k per year that we thought Trump was implementing was ideal, it would kill most early career immigration and keep the good folks that I don’t have a problem with. On that note, even the O1 has got to go, a highly paid H1b is far better technically than the average O1, there are all sorts of scams going on in the O1 system with buying conference papers, reference letters, judging worthless competitions etc etc.

In the end, this is a question of will, there are very simple solutions, we don’t even need an operation wetback 2.0, a few simple rules and we can get rid of 90% of such immigration.

Kallias's avatar

I find myself wishing I were more sympathetic. Like you and your examples, I harbored some admiration for elements of Indian culture. Especially its history of religion, as I would discuss regularly with a Hindu (a convert, but very theologically minded) friend of mine. Surely there must be something that fascinated the world in general, and the minds of Anglo luminaries in particular, about a land they tried so long and so desperately to have as their own.

And yet I find myself now simply out of patience. Whatever the wonders of the Subcontinent, its history, culture, religion, etc., the constant, day in and day out, actions and behaviors of its people are so far removed from those formidable heights it seems the only rational conclusion is that there's simply no connection between the achievements of the past and the people today. Even as Indians themselves thump their chests over it, it all comes off a bit like Boomer conservative reference for the Founders or Constitution: endlessly counting one's (alleged) ancestors more dearly than one's sons.

You make a heartful appeal to those genuinely capable, talented Indians. Those that must surely have endured much to escape what are genuinely among the most wretched conditions still on Earth. And yet, over and over, we're subject to these "elite" emigres siding time and against with the very worst aspects of their society. Dinesh D'souza, someone who's been in the US for forty years and has probably few familial ties to his country of origin, recently boasting that the future belongs to poo-throwers, comes to mind. Like he's gleeful even now to hurl people he himself would have nothing to do with as missiles at non-Indians. To harbor such gloating resentment for so long would almost be impressive in its determination, if it weren't so tirelessly predictable.

I suppose in the end, it just feels like it's all been one massive fraud. A Potemkin culture propped up by 19th century Anglo fascination in the other that has long since faded to reality. One that was evident as early as the ballads of Kipling (himself quite enamored with India and having lived there nearly all his life) making sharp critiques of the locals' shameless striver mentality. Even though I agree much of the critique has lost substance and devolved into zero-effort copycat posting for clout, the fatigue is real, and I suspect we're all going to be waiting a long time before their "highly skilled, elite human capital," develops any qualms over their frankly cartoonish cruelty.

Lamp Post's avatar

BAP addressed this in the article, if you saw. He said it’s a classical/antique “flavor” of the highest heights existing alongside the lowest lows (in human quality terms).

From my personal experience, knowing Indians/other desis from across the gamut of castes and regions, I think he’s definitely right. I’ve known (desi) artists & musicians, electrical engineers, inventors, all of whom were genuinely good (and I say that as a highly disagreeable heritage American who is not so easily impressed), and I’ve known convenience store owners and Mirpuri (yes we have them too) criminal retards that made me wonder why exactly I pay taxes if this is what the government does to my city.

The salient point now is that the numbers are unassimilable, irreconcilable, even if we were *trying* to assimilate them (which as BAP points out we don’t). But that fact doesn’t remove the obvious reality that many subcons of genuine quality are here, and there is much to like about India and (good) Indians, while still acknowledging that we shouldn’t let any more move here, should probably deport most of those already here, and should certainly disenfranchise that whole population in terms of political and judicial power.

Gene Gamer's avatar

You people don't help your case when you use words like “frankly cartoonish cruelty" and “harbor such gloating resentment for so long", especially if you're an anglo. What do you think was a reasonable middle ground after the anglos having leeched off everything they could from India. I won't say “45 trillion" but the anglos did come to India only to extract wealth and that was their whole incentive for two centuries. They left the country poorer than subsaharan Africa and now you're mad that the descendants of those people have enough agency to thrive in your home at your expense, in the least violent way possible?

The fatigue you have is real and if I was in your shoes I'd think so too but the white fatigue is much older and more intolerable at this point with the most vocal complaints about tech workers being replaced coming from people whose entire lives revolve around America's God, politics. Most Indians don't come to America with an idea of exacting revenge but simply because there's better opportunities, but the discourse has demonized Indians to the point that this framework is how the ruling cabinet now operates with. Don't be surprised when the other side recognizes it and acts accordingly.

Every civilization has its ups and downs and the conquerors don't just get to walk away and not integrate with the conquered. Ask the Romans who enslaved the Greeks if it worked out for them, when their slaves were far wiser and more productive than the masters they were forced to serve.

Patel Motel's avatar

"Most Indians don't come to America with an idea of exacting revenge but simply because there's better opportunities, but the discourse has demonized Indians to the point that this framework is how the ruling cabinet now operates with."

What do you think was the genesis of this demonization? Where did it spring from? What is the motivation?

Gene Gamer's avatar

Simple ethnic resentment won't do it for you? 20th century was unprecedented in human history so a bunch of problems were offset by it. Now, opportunities are drying up and more people are competing for a shrinking pool of opportunities. They see immigrants come in and succeed which is worse than importing an underclass from central america, per the modal citizen thing BAP talked about.

Patel Motel's avatar

Nothing about Indians' low trust behavior? Building 100 foot statues on deities on the landscape? Voting against the interests of heritage Americans 80% of time?

Patel Motel's avatar

As one of these Indians in America (though came much much earlier than the recent surge) who loves America and American culture (at least the culture that existed in the 80s and 90s but unfortunately does not today), I largely agree with the article with some small counters below. First some comments towards Indians if you're reading this:

1) Indians need to recognize they are cheap labor. Yes, that's right, you are cheap labor. In the current surge, you are white collar Mexicans. Your immigration surge has been sold to the public as "skilled labor" but make no mistake, you are cheap commodity labor being used to replace white Americans who cost more to employ than you.

Why would whites do this? Just as there are Hindus in India that work against the thriving of Hinduism in India and want nothing more than the destruction of Hindu civilization, there are whites in America who want nothing more than to see whites suffer.

2) You did not invent Silicon Valley. American innovation existed long before there was a single Indian in America and would continue if every single Indian was deported.

3) You know how Muslims will block the road and start praying in groups? You know the motivation there: it's a flex and a dare: "What are you going to do about it?" A softer version of that is building giant statues of Hindu deities on the American landscape that can be seen by the public from afar. There are no giant statues of Jesus or Mary on the landscape nor even giant crosses. Be polite toward the host culture and stop that shit right now.

4) Have some appreciation for why America "works" and India doesn't. America will stop working if too many Indians come all at once.

5) Stop blaming Americans for historic British actions. America was also part of the colonial project. They fought (and defeated) in war the British.

6) Why come to America if you're only going to congregate among other Indians? Do you just want India with better infrastructure?

7) Just because Indians came to America in the past does not mean that every Indian has a right to come to America forever. There's a time and place for immigration and these circumstances change over time. America is currently heading toward a huge slowdown, and perhaps even a complete stop in immigration.

Notes to BAP and Indian skeptics:

1) While I appreciate the ideas of the Vedas, there's a slightly different aspect by which I appreciate Hinduism: that of divinity in all things, whether nature, the self, the Universe, or other people. We offer prayers to the Sun upon rising, revere the nature around us, hold sacred the cow which feeds us and our children, bless the food which nourishes us before each meal by first offering to the gods, revere the knowledge which enlightens us (never to touch a book with our feet), bow down before our parents that raise us, and try to become one with the Universe which created us. There's divinity in all things to greater or lesser degrees. These ideas are better distilled in the Upanishads which I think you've praised before.

(To others, you might only know about Hinduism through monkey gods and elephant gods, but Hinduism is a rich philosophical tradition whose essential idea--"dharma"--is basically way to seek ways to build civilization.)

2) I think your characterization of Patels and of other Indians' views of Patels is off. Patels are a hard working, simple living, fairly uncorrupt (IMO) group. In America they are much more likely to vote conservative, and Gujarat is the most pro Hindu state in India, least tolerant of Islamic shenanigans, and the most highly developed as well. They are traditionally NOT a mercantile caste, but rather a farmer or "kulak" status. Most Indians respect Gujaratis. See these threads on Quora (a great place to mine for sentiment about all things India).

https://www.quora.com/What-do-other-Indians-think-of-Gujaratis-What-instantly-comes-to-your-mind-when-youre-told-someones-a-Gujarati

IMO, the sentiment among Indians toward Gujaratis is similar to what Americans think of Mormons, or did so about 10-20 years ago.

Note that most of the elite Indian-Americans who work against Americans (Vijaya Gadde, Sundar Pichai, Saira Rao, the Silicon Valley elite, etc) are not Patels or Gujaratis. The typical South Indian elite tech worker in San Francisco is much more likely to look down upon everyday Americans, embrace wokism, and vote Democrat.

3) I appreciate your views of what India would be like without Hinduism. IMO, it would turn into Pakistan or Afghanistan. Not a mode for thriving. India can only thrive with Hinduism, which is why it's risen to prominence under the first Hindu-first leader in the better part of a thousand years (Modi).

4) Also appreciate your thoughts on what Europe and America might be like under a polytheistic order. While in my lifetime, Christianity falling has resulted in a worsening of the culture, and I wish Christianity would make a comeback as a bulwark against wokism, the European people have thrived before under polytheism (Greek history and most of Roman history) and might thrive again.

Patel Motel's avatar

I should add that despite my chosen handle, neither I nor my family are in the Motel business. That's was a tongue-in-cheek choice of name.

Commander Nelson's avatar

"there are whites in America who want nothing more than to see whites suffer." ... yes but all of these are either women or Jews.

Patel Motel's avatar

What you say is largely true, but there are a lot of gentile white males in the Northeast, along the West Coast, in academia, media, marketing, and board rooms who absolutely hate white America.

Lamp Post's avatar

See the Nick Land tweet. “Never get so racist that you forget white leftists are the worst people in existence”. Obviously there exist white (male) leftists—unless you think all European males in the US were pathetically conquered by women and jews, somehow? FDR and LBJ and their many supporters I suppose being women, or jewish?

Every old white man at the no kings protest being jewish too, in your imagination? Every MSNBC-watching zombie retard, too?

Commander Nelson's avatar

There are always a few exceptions to prove the rule.

Lamp Post's avatar

It’s not a few, it’s like 30+% of white male voters who vote Democrat. Not even close to 30% of white men are jewish

Francis LaPierre's avatar

41% of white male voters supported Kamala Harris in the 2024 U.S. presidential election. AP VoteCast data. That’s a lot of white non Jewish men

WeepingWillow's avatar

All rationality and reason is useless at this point regarding the Indians. Unfortunately for them, being fellaheen tropical people's they tend to illicit a disgust response in Northern Europeans and their colonial descendents.

All the post hoc intellectualised analysis is just cover for something that is felt very deep in the bones once exposure reaches a certain point and economic times turn tough. It's also one of the reasons the Japanese and Koreans are far more tolerated, they are similarly temperate people's that easily adapted to western mores.

It's why our women don't care at all about letting fly with racist vitriol towards them, as the disgust response is strongest in them. The women hatred is also far more concerning long term for their safety as they are the far crueler sex.

Note how Protestant people's (Anglo-Germanic) in subtropical climates (South Africa, American South, Northern Australia) have always had far more exclusionist policies towards ethnic mixing than those who stayed in the cooler climates, the latter of whom only had to deal with foreigners in the abstract. Now that the more equatorial people's have gone as far as the temperate homelands those who live there are starting to mirror similar attitudes. Catholics always mixed readily, and this to me hits at the ethnic differences between southern and northern Europeans and the phenotype retention drive of the northerns.

Nick's avatar

"to show them the argument against Indian migration isn’t motivated by bigotry or racism, but is based on common sense. (...) I love Indian food and will continue to, no matter what, with special love for south Indian coconut curries and many such spice things Malabar. I love Indian music and share the 1960’s Hippies’ admiration for Ravi Shankar and the like…"

Is this the "Bronze Age Pervert" or some washed out hippie writing for Vox?

Clementine's avatar

To be honest, I think the fact that the sheer degree of diplomatic language in this post is necessary will make it insufficient. Any people with the capacity for self-awareness would have been convinced by the self-evident truth that they are making peoples that could conquer them with a thousand riflemen hate them with all of their hearts. Being allowed to behave the way that they have been behaving has pushed their already very limited capacity for introspection past the event horizon.

I don't think there's any diplomatic resolution, here. It ends when a vengeful tide of White male 20-somethings seizes power, cuts off the remittances, and sends the ones who didn't lash out on social media back to India unharmed, sans their belongings. Trying to negotiate something neater is like trying to convince Ben Shapiro not to dig himself any deeper, and Benji's got 30 IQ points on this lot.

Quixotic Rambler's avatar

What happened to the Italians with the RICO act will come down on Indians in America as well, though probably much more subdued because they’re more spread out across the country, as opposed to one region like the Italians

Clementine's avatar

I'm skeptical of the comparison. Italians did not go out of their way to make the people around them miserable, and were ultimately capable of success and assimilation on a level playing field. You could neatly amputate organized crime from their social structure and still be left with something meaningful after it was gone.

The current wave of Indian migrants was brought in solely to make life worse for the native population. They don't have the option of happily assimilating into America, they are backed solely by a ruling class that wants obedient intermediaries, and their options after that ruling class falls are nonexistent.

Gene Gamer's avatar

No, the options they have after the ruling class fails are violence, which is what you people are edging towards. It would be very funny if WW3 happened because white zoomers had black tier ethnonarcissim and blamed the world for their failures. What's happening now is what happens every time two civilizations clash and one comes out on top: the conquered people won't just sit down for centuries and not try to extract wealth the same way the conquerors did. You people are quick to point out that companies don't hire you because hiring Indians is good for them in the short term at the expense of long term quality, but don't have the foresight to see the anglos of the last 3 centuries in the same light. They left the world's richest nation poorer than subsaharan Africa for their short term gains and you think their descendants would've just taken that face down and not even try their hand in the new world? Who asked England to find colonialism as the easiest way to prosperity?

Your problem is that you're ethnonarcissists and comparatively unagentic to boot. Everything needs to be someone else's fault that you're not winning. If someone who didn't even grow up with your language is succeeding in your home more than you, maybe someday have some humility to think how much of it is your fault than to just see them as malicious actors.

The most insulting thing to me in all this discourse isn't the brimestone tier name calling and insulting our gods, because that's just low IQ seething, but the way many anons on twitter gloat about colonialism while being offensively stupidly blindsided about the repercussions of it. You're living them, and you could've never escaped them in any alternate timeline. I mean it with no malice to you.

Clementine's avatar

> you think their descendants would've just taken that face down

You paint yourselves as righteous rebels wanting revenge. I'm not going to humor that self-important schlock. You came here on a leash, you know full well who let you in, and you serve them even more slavishly than you served the British. Ask the British how they treat useful tools. The Brits at least had IQs of 100 and decent hygiene - Israelis can tolerate a day with a Brit, but they feel the same disgust at an Indian as everyone else on the planet.

You want a historical metaphor? You are ZOG's Tutsis, if the Hutus stood nine inches taller, if the Hutus had twenty more IQ points on average, and if the Tutsis had the arrogance to spend every moment as privileged intermediaries making the Hutus hate them more.

Gene Gamer's avatar

The more I see people like you resent someone just looking for better opportunities and taking them the more I realize you people really would prefer an all out war. It's so tiresome talking to whites, always yapping about IQ and the noise comes from terminally politically active people who wouldn't get a job at Google if the hiring policy was "white men only". The average white zoomer does not have an IQ of 100, you people couldn't do single variable algebra at 16 and the racial distribution of SAT scores proved that, before your country stopped using them out of embarrassment.

Have a good one, you will never get your jobs back. Even with 100% remigration, openai/google/anthropic won't hire you and in a decade all white collar work will be automated by ASI, we're actually working very hard towards that end. Then we'll settle our grievances the old fashioned way when everyone is part of the permanent underclass. That's what you're looking forward to with or without immigration.

V900's avatar

What’s wrong with bigotry when it comes to Indians? From their unsanitary, backwards culture to the way they termite-like dig in to whatever company that gets an Indian middle manager.*

There’s nothing wrong with bigotry against Indians. It’s self defense.

*Take ANY company that hires an Indian middle manager, and visit it a year later. Somehow, as if by magic, it has gone from a majority white workplace to AT LEAST 50% Indian. And always from his particular subgroup/clan of Jeets.

Patel Motel's avatar

This phenomenon is almost surely due to commands from the top. CEO or VP decides: let's lower the cost structure by hiring Indians. They hire a company like Cognizant or simply some Indian middle manager with the directive: replace everyone with an Indian. It's not driven by the middle manager.

Here's a secret: Indians don't like each other. Hence the low trust society. They don't want each other to succeed. They don't want to help each other. When you note a phenomenon like what you observe, there's a much more likely explanation than "they only hire their own."

Daniella Pentsak's avatar

The myth of meritocracy was expunged the moment it was manufactured by Harvard elites, namely James Bryant Conant. The results of that are irreversible. The neo-slavery we are conducting ourselves in now through the importation of workers is a way to not resolve that but adapt to it.

Yonah Ha-I (יוֹנָה הָאִי)'s avatar

Us Jews destroyed meritocracy in America. Why waste chutzpah on such a pointless lie? Stop slinging WASPs, our only allies, into the mud.

Nicet Ryfed's avatar

Great article friend, and in return I will say that I have great appreciation for your book and show. Though I have had to seperate myself from almost all RW sectors now due to the absolute hostility, I will always treasure your work, along with that of some others like Agent, Moldbug, and Land.

I have chosen not to emigrate, despite various opportunities, because I wish to stay and build here. There’s amazing potential, both human and economic, simply lying there because most educated Indians are pushed to get out and pursue a career or higher education in a place where they aren’t discriminated against. (We have had our own equivalent of what white americans are experiencing now, except with lower castes and tribes being given privileges and quotas over the rest instead of races)

Now that the Chinese are allied with us and less retarded communists are getting put into power, great changes are already happening, like the recent developments in industry under Stalin in Tamil Nadu, and there will be far less negative incentive for emigration. I wish you all the best, and I hope America will get more leaders like Trump who stifle immigration and provide opportunities for the natives.

Ernst Younger's avatar

Can you speak more of this Chinese alliance? From everything Ive read on twitter and media, there seems to be not only historical animosity but structural, unresolvable tensions stemming from two great countries sharing a land border. Although there is subsection of indian twitter that I follow which advocates for less kanging to “learn from the chinese example”. Anyways, very curious abt ur take on the situation and how the domestic (non-internet?) sentiment is on chinese cooperation

Rajeev Ram's avatar

I find nothing substantial in this essay to disagree with. Well done.

– A 2nd-Generation TamBrahm American Citizen

(who also shares your deep affinity for sculpted, well-oiled chest muscles)

Matt Snow's avatar

Hello BAP, this is my first post on substack. I read your book and I read Nietzsche. I have never had twitter. I am a subscriber to your gumroad since episode 100. I have a CS degree since covid and I have been working in a warehouse since then.

The indian and chinese replacement of American programmers is my single voter issue because I taught myself how to code since I was 13 and I have never been able to discharge my talents through even a foot in the door 20 years later.

Now it feels hopeless because of my student debt and other inflationary bills while I'm trying to keep a job that pays not much more than minimum wage while I have a wife and child to feed.

It is humiliating to work under lesser skilled and illiterate managers who benefit from DEI and gay privilege; people who give their friends fake staffing roles with little to no workload while shifting all the heavy work to all the heterosexual males. Policies are also unevenly enforced on us but not on them and their friends.

I live in a ghetto mexican neighborhood in a city that is 90% mexican and they play mariachi at night until 3 am every weekend. On weekends it is impossible to eat at a restaurant because they are flooded with olds and huge mexican families. To get away, I take myself and my family to parks in nice expensive neighborhoods 20 to 40 minutes away and when I get there, I see no Americans. Instead, There are indians and chinese at these parks who are most certainly the ones living in these expensive houses nearby because they are the ones who took the high paying careers from people like me.

My last hope is to gamble on crypto and stocks so that I can escape this hell. After voting for trump since 2016, I have decided I will not vote anymore. I eat spam from a can to save money while I wait for change.

Grant Dyer's avatar

This is well done and balanced. As was Enoch's speech, a man who loved India. I will spell it out for you . This is BAPs 'rivers of blood' speech on the future for Indians and Americans if the Indians and American establishment continue with current immigration and employment practices:

'As I look ahead, I am filled with foreboding; like the Roman,

I seem to see "the River Tiber foaming with much blood."

Jonathon's avatar

Such hedged views of immigrants are typical of older folk on this side of the divide, who despite apparent alignments tend to be more well-established in life and have a vested interest in not rocking the boat.

Younger people have less and so can be more open in expressing their dislike of Denisovan hybrids.

Eventually the opinions of the old will become irrelevant, because they will die of the same old age that gave them a head start. And young people need not retain dead opinions that do not materially benefit them.

Vedicarya's avatar

While I believe your feelings for India are sincere (and interest in Hinduism),

Indian emigration (and by extension South Asian immigration too) is majority non Hindu.

Indian immigrants are also a small minority in the US and Hindu immigrants are even smaller among the overall share of South Asian immigrants in the UK or Canada.

Of course some Indian immigrants are “elite” which breed suspicion, but most aren’t. Even then people purposely ignore low crime rates and contributions of average Indians (like doctors for example) and gas up anything negative they perceive - purely on anecdote.

But even then even if its a Sikh, Muslim, or Christian (like Dinesh D Souza) what is the target? Hinduism

So when Hinduism is attacked and propaganda is promoted endlessly, despite these factors, it comes off as not even about immigration at all to Indians.

When Indian leftists openly join in and promote this too (who are blatantly genocidal towards Hindus in India at this point), it comes off not as about Indian immigration at all but an assault towards India and Hinduism itself. At a time when Hindus themselves feel their own demographic anxieties about Hindus (like the West might about white demographics).

Hindus also you know, have been attacked historically by Christians and Muslims. So all this does is “validate” their own suspicions too.

People in the west arguing with Hindus online are not aware that many are in India itself (seriously so many right wing Indians i’ve met on X are just from India itself and they speak good english and know western slang).

Westerners are involving themselves in Indian politics. Indian leftists fan the flames using their propaganda. This ultimately is the biggest reason why Indians have become so outwardly anti western lately and straight up hostile now.

I realize you’re not like that so I respect it and value your opinion on this matter, but the post you reference by Matt Forney outwardly attacks Right Wing politics in India. Which itself makes me suspicious on his motives.

You can’t expect Indians to be sympathetic to conservatism and nationalism in the West (which they once were by the way) when that same respect isn’t shared for India at its home.

Again you’re the voice that would bridge that hostility so I admire your tweets.